CORPORAL PUNISHMENT Essay

Positive Effects of Corporal PunishmentCorporal avengement in regards to beat up has been used for hundreds of years in educational systems and in house holds and is still legal in all fifty states for p arents to use in there household because it is an effective way to punish a child for wrong mien. Even though in the last couple of decades this topic has been very controversial, many countries and educational systems have decided to illegalise corporal punishment because of the belief that it has created more and more untrained behavior in children. precisely, there is still no draw a bead on draw to full of life cause children to have more angry behavior. However, if y poph violence and dysfunction is increasing at the same time that corporal punishment is decreasing, we should be open comme il faut to consider whether the two trends are related. Maybe there is no connection. besides maybe lawmakers and child welfare workers should pay more attention to the research suggesting that fleshly discipline can be helpful in certain contexts (Larzelere,2005). The whole reason for punishment is to gag rule a behavior from happening again by applying an unpleasant stimulus straight after a bad behavior has occurred. Therefore, we use corporal punishment because it is a method of punishment called punishment by application which spanking is applied to the child after a bad behavior, preventing it from happening again, which also help implement discipline.But corporal punishment is universe apposed because other studies say it promotes more anger and aggression in juveniles, but places where it has been totally outlawed have shown different results. For instance, after Sweden outlawed spanking, violent behavior did not decrease. Instead, there has been substantially more violence in Sweden than ever before violence by children, violence by parents, and violence by connection in general (Grusec, 1994). That being said, there is no direct link to corp oral punishment being the cause of violence increase because this shows it did just the opposite. But research does show that it could be linked tosomething else, journalist Patricia Hersch tells of the deluge of adolescent dysfunction sweeping the nation, manifesting itself in everything from drugs, sex, and underachievement to depression, suicide, and crime and it is being hearn in upstarter and younger children. About 20% of kids straight have some sort of developmental, seeing, or behavioral disorder. And as the Carnegie Council on Adolescent Development warns, substantial numbers of American youth are at risk of reaching adulthood unable to meet adequately the requirements of the workplace, the commitments of relationships in families and with friends, and the responsibilities of participation in a democratic society.(Hersch, 1998) And a lot of this is being caused by the lack of parenthood and how parents are raising their kids now days with substantially fewer parents st aying home with their kids and we have become given over to TV, movies, and videogames (Rosemond, 1989). Parents dont have to attend to their kids as much because they just put a T.V. or some kind of videogame system in motility of them to keep them occupied. Thus, giving the kids less interaction with other people and their parents, which can lead to bad relationships and also antisocial which leads to aggression as vigorous. So we see all these things that easily effect our children and their behavior but people still try to link all of it back to corporal punishment when we should look at the big picture.A common misunderstanding is how to use corporal punishment manufacturely, and the primary goal most parents have in administering corporal punishment is to stop children from misbehaving immediately (Gershoff, 2002) and is indeed a good method when used correctly. When a parent is using corporal punishment out of anger, frustration, or aggression, the child leave alone lear n that same action you apply on them. Therefore, the punishment can be classified as abuse to an extent and when pain is being labored on a child out of your own aggression and anger they learn those same attributes and those later on cause behavioral problems down the road. But when used just to stop a specific behavior with out trying to inflict pain on the child is when it is most effective, and yes spanking is a primitive discipline method. But a childs mind is also primitive. As researchers like Dr. Jean Piaget of the University of Geneva have popularized, kids learn from the visible to the intangiblefrom the concrete to the abstract. It is duringthe tangible, concrete stages when physical discipline seems to be the most helpful (Fuller, 2010). Thus, when using corporal punishment correctly and not abusively, the child understands immediately at a younger age. It is just like a dog, you need to train them at a very young age for the training to be most effective. Same thing g oes for children because at a young age is when it becomes concrete, and just like dogs again, and when they start getting older its harder to get children to obey, and you argot teach a dog new tricks.But statistics from Sears, Maccoby, and Levin (1957) show that they found that 99% of the children they studied experienced CP at least occasionally. If thats true and corporal punishment causes aggression, promotes violent activities, and learning disabilities like people say then why doesnt everyone have aggression, behavior problems, and learning disabilities? They dont because spanking is to be better at controlling aggression than mental punishments like timeout, reasoning, scolding, non-contact punishment, privilege removal, love withdrawal, or diverting. Also showing that calm and controlled spanking, and spanking in response to defiance, is uniformly more beneficial than other punishments. (Larzelere,2005)Growing up in a household where corporal punishment was definitely used by my parents, I feel my experience has had a huge impact on me because it has honestly helped me now more than anything. I say that because at a young age I learned fast what was right and wrong and have always been able to pick up onto things fast, and as I grew up I might have had some family problems and what not but I feel like me being develop at such a young age, it has unbroken with me all along. And Im not just disciplined because I think I will be punished or something, but I have learned to be more, Ive learned to be self-disciplined, and being disciplined has helped me in school, sports, living life on a daily basis, and my future. And that is some other reason I believe corporal punishment is effective it teaches discipline at such a young age, and with discipline comes responsibility, and these two traits are expose for healthy lifestyle not just at a young age but through your whole life. Because no matter how old you are their will always be a punishment for you r disobedience, whether its disobeying your parents or itsdisobeying a police officer, either way your going to have to disciplined enough to take responsibility for your actions. And if your making bad decisions or choices then youll probably have a worse punishment whether its a spanking or you go to prison. Punishments just get worse as we get older so might as well be disciplined now then end up in jail.In conclusion, I see corporal punishment as a very effective way for children to learn not to disobey your parents but to also just be obedient in general. Even though some researchers say it has evidence leading to violent behaviors and aggression, their research seems to be inadequate when it comes to the results and observations of research. Research trying to support the outlaw of corporal punishment even says the evidence presented is not strong enough to leave a conclusion that it has been proven that smacking causes long term adverse effects on children (Larzelere,2005). Proving my point that corporal punishment is not a direct link to issues down the line, and I would like to reinforce that corporal punishment is an effective way of punishment if used for the right reason and depending on the context of the behavior, and that it has personally directed me and influenced me in more of a positive way.AbstractAfter using the information I was able to gather from R. E. Larzelere, J. E. Grusec, P. Hersch, as well as J. Rosemod to help support my idea that corporal punishment is still an effective way of punishment in todays society. Even though there is so many argued topics on the issue at the moment, I still concluded from my research that corporal punishment has no direct link to violence, aggression, and behavioral problems. Even after looking at evidence from E. Gershoff that tries to support the idea that corporal punishment causes behavioral problems as well as violent behaviors, a thorough understanding of whether and how corporal punishment aff ects children has not been reached. It hasnt been reached because the research that is being used is unreliable and some of the parents are not aware(predicate) of how to properly use corporal punishment on a child, so they are actually doing harm to their child because they are punishing the child out of anger rather than the sole reason to stop a behavior. Therefore, I believecorporal punishment is an effective way of punishment and helps direct children the correct way down the road in life with quality traits like discipline, responsibility, and respecting and obeying your authorities.ReferenceRobert E. Larzelere & Brett R. Kuhn, Comparing Child Outcomes of Physical Punishment and Alternative Disciplinary tactical maneuver A Meta-Analysis, 8 CLINICAL CHILD & FAM. PSYCHOL. REV. 1, 32 (2005) hereinafter Larzelere, Meta-Analysis Joan E. Grusec & Jacqueline J. Goodnow, Impact of Parental Discipline Methods on the Childs Internalization of Values A Reconceptualization of occurrent Points of View, 30 DEV. PSYCHOL. 7 (1994) PATRICIA HERSCH, A TRIBE APART A JOURNEY INTO THE HEART OF AMERICAN ADOLESCENCE 12 (1998) JOHN ROSEMOND, JOHN ROSEMONDS SIX-POINT PLAN FOR nip and tuck HAPPY, HEALTHY CHILDREN 179-80 (1989) Gershoff, E. (2002). Corporal punishment by parents and associated child behaviors and experiences A meta-analytic and theoretical review.Psychological Bulletin, 128(4), 539-579. Retrieved from http//www.comm.umn.edu/akoerner/courses/4471-F12/Readings/Gershoff (2002).pdf